# light-idea-critique

> Light 科研主线第 4 步·审 idea：以**顶会审稿人标准严审** idea，**撞车/无创新 fatal flaw 一票否决**(critical 门)， 逼出真能发表的 idea。何时用：用户问"这 idea 行不行/够不够新…

Light 科研主线第 4 步·审 idea：以**顶会审稿人标准严审** idea，**撞车/无创新 fatal flaw 一票否决**(critical 门)， 逼出真能发表的 idea。何时用：用户问"这 idea 行不行/够不够新/能不能发""帮我严审/挑刺/找致命问题" / idea 定稿前把关 / 收到 idea-generation 的候选要审 / 怀疑撞车(被人做过)。触发词：审 idea / 评审 / 严审 / 挑刺 / 这 idea 行不行 / 够不够新 / 创新性 / 撞车 / 被做过了吗 / 致命问题 / 能投顶会吗 / 拒稿风险 / critique my idea / review this idea / is this novel / fatal flaw / 一票否决。核心纪律：**撞车/无创新的 critical 一票否决在本技能**(不被其他高维度平均救回)； **硬性反谄媚**(不被作者反复反驳顺从放行弱 idea)；撞车判定**target/background 可追溯分解**非"感觉像"；judge 不靠裸 自评(用可计算否决闸门 + 密度先验 + pairwise)。**消费上游 idea-generation 的撞车 findings + facet 槽位**。

- Type: Skill
- Made by: Light0305
- Category: Research
- Formats: Skills
- Version: 3.1.0-round3
- Source: https://github.com/light0305/light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique
- Page: https://pluginboard.ai/skills/light-idea-critique

## Works with

- ChatGPT
- Claude
- Gemini
- GitHub Copilot
- Cursor
- Claude Code
- Codex
- Antigravity
- Gemini CLI
- Replit
- OpenClaw
- OpenCode
- Hermes Agent

## Install

### ChatGPT

In ChatGPT: Download the light-idea-critique folder and zip it, then Plugins → Skills → Create → Upload from your computer. Business and Enterprise plans.

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### Claude

In Claude (web or desktop): Download the light-idea-critique folder and zip the folder itself, then upload it in Customize → Skills.

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### Gemini

In Gemini: Download the light-idea-critique folder, then at gemini.google.com click Customize → Skills → Create → Upload and pick the folder (or a .zip of it).

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### GitHub Copilot

Run in your terminal:

```shell
npx -y degit Light0305/Light-skills/skills/light-idea-critique ~/.copilot/skills/light-idea-critique
```

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### Cursor

Run in your terminal:

```shell
npx -y degit Light0305/Light-skills/skills/light-idea-critique ~/.cursor/skills/light-idea-critique
```

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### Claude Code

Run in your terminal:

```shell
npx -y degit Light0305/Light-skills/skills/light-idea-critique ~/.claude/skills/light-idea-critique
```

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### Codex

Run in your terminal:

```shell
npx -y degit Light0305/Light-skills/skills/light-idea-critique ~/.agents/skills/light-idea-critique
```

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### Antigravity

In Antigravity: Copy the light-idea-critique folder into ~/.gemini/config/skills (Antigravity app and IDE) or ~/.gemini/antigravity-cli/skills (Antigravity CLI).

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### Gemini CLI

Run in your terminal:

```shell
npx -y degit Light0305/Light-skills/skills/light-idea-critique ~/.gemini/skills/light-idea-critique
```

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### Replit

Run in your terminal:

```shell
npx -y degit Light0305/Light-skills/skills/light-idea-critique .agents/skills/light-idea-critique
```

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### OpenClaw

Run in your terminal:

```shell
npx -y degit Light0305/Light-skills/skills/light-idea-critique ~/.openclaw/skills/light-idea-critique
```

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### OpenCode

Run in your terminal:

```shell
npx -y degit Light0305/Light-skills/skills/light-idea-critique ~/.config/opencode/skills/light-idea-critique
```

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

### Hermes Agent

Run in your terminal:

```shell
npx -y degit Light0305/Light-skills/skills/light-idea-critique ~/.hermes/skills/light-idea-critique
```

View the folder on GitHub: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/light-idea-critique

---
From Pluginboard (https://pluginboard.ai).